Cartmasters
Free store check

By Teddy

Where the site loses sales, and the changes most likely to win them back.

22 Nov 2026Prepared by Tim Fowler, CartmastersBased on your live site on 22 Nov 2026
Pages looked at
4
On desktop and phone, as a shopper sees them
Ideas
5
Best first
Competitors compared
2
First phone screen, same day
Scorecard
12/20
Checks passed, of those that apply

By Teddy already does a lot right: lovely product photos of dogs wearing the pieces, a 5.0 rating from 1,324 reviews, and Black Friday discounts that apply by themselves. The clearest gaps are on a phone product page, where the banner pushes the product below the first screen, and in delivery, where the product page and the shipping policy give two different free delivery figures (£75 and £40). This is a first look from the public pages only, so we have not seen your sales numbers or the checkout itself.

Want a hand with these?

Reply to the email this came in, or get in touch, and we will talk the top ideas through with you. No obligation.

Get in touchor just reply to the email
Tim Fowler, Founder and Shopify developer, Cartmasters
What to change

5 ideas, best first

Ranked by how much each is likely to help, judged from your pages, and how sure we are. Each one says what we found, where it comes from, and the next step.

1
ChangeMedium

Let the product, not the banner, fill the first phone screen

Product pages on a phone

Suggested change

Now: Product page on a phone: the tall Black Friday banner becomes one slim line, so the photo, product name and price rise into the first screen.
Now
Suggested: Product page on a phone: the tall Black Friday banner becomes one slim line, so the photo, product name and price rise into the first screen.
Suggested, with the change boxed

The offer tiers are your own (20% off any item, 25% off any 2, 30% off any 3 or more), as your banner and top bar show them.

What we found

  • Your pagesOn a phone the product page opens on the Black Friday banner and photo; the name, price and Add to cart all start below the first screen.
  • Your pagesThe same three offer tiers already show in the top bar and in the progress bar under Add to cart.
  • CompetitorMutts & Hounds shows the product name, photo and an Add to cart bar in the first phone screen.

The idea

Because on a phone the Black Friday banner sits above the product photo and pushes the name, price and Add to cart below the first screen, we think a one-line offer strip will bring the product and its price into view at once, for phone shoppers opening a product page. The same holds for any banner placed there after the sale ends.

Reach
Everyone who opens a product page
Impact
HighAmong the biggest wins in this audit
How sure
MediumBacked by your pages and what competitors do
Next step
Test it firstIt changes the first thing phone shoppers see on every product page, so compare it with the current page.
Measure it by: Add to cart rate on phone product pages
2
FixHunch

Make the free delivery figure the same everywhere

Product page Shipping tab and shipping policy
The closed Shipping tab on the phone product page, where the £75 figure sits.
The closed Shipping tab on the phone product page, where the £75 figure sits.

What we found

  • Your pagesThe product page's Shipping tab says "Complimentary UK Shipping Over £75".
  • Your storeYour shipping policy says UK standard delivery is "free when you spend over £40".
  • Best practiceA delivery promise that changes from page to page makes shoppers doubt the rest.

The idea

Because the product page's Shipping tab says "Complimentary UK Shipping Over £75" while the shipping policy says UK standard delivery is free when you spend over £40, we think showing one figure in both places will stop shoppers being put off or surprised, for UK shoppers with a basket between £40 and £75. Which figure checkout charges was not checked.

Reach
Everyone who opens a product page
Impact
HighAmong the biggest wins in this audit
How sure
HunchBacked by your pages and good practice
Next step
Just do itTwo figures for the same promise is a fix, not a test.
Measure it by: Checkout starts from the basket
3
NewMedium

Put delivery and returns facts next to Add to cart

Product pages

Suggested change

Now: Product page on a phone: a delivery and returns row with three line icons sits under Add to cart and the offer bar.
Now
Suggested: Product page on a phone: a delivery and returns row with three line icons sits under Add to cart and the offer bar.
Suggested, with the change boxed

Every line is from your own shipping and returns policy: UK standard 2 to 4 working days, Royal Mail, dispatched within 2 to 3 working days, returns within 14 days of delivery.

What we found

  • Your pagesDelivery is only inside the closed Shipping tab, and returns are only in the footer.
  • Your storeYour policy: dispatched within 2 to 3 working days, UK standard 2 to 4 working days by Royal Mail, returns within 14 days of delivery.
  • CompetitorMutts & Hounds puts "Free delivery on all UK orders over £150." with a van icon under Add to cart.

The idea

Because delivery times and the 14 day returns window are only in a closed Shipping tab and the policy pages, we think a short row under Add to cart with dispatch, delivery and returns will answer the last questions before buying, for product page shoppers. The free delivery figure can join the row once one figure is settled.

Reach
Everyone who opens a product page
Impact
MediumA solid win, behind the top ideas
How sure
MediumBacked by your pages and what competitors do
Next step
Test it firstIt adds a block beside the buy button, so check it lifts adds to cart rather than distracting.
Measure it by: Add to cart rate on product pages
4
FixHunch

Keep the review pop-up off the basket and the main photo on phones

Basket and product pages on a phone

Suggested change

Now: The basket on a phone: the floating review card no longer sits over the checkout buttons.
Now
Suggested: The basket on a phone: the floating review card no longer sits over the checkout buttons.
Suggested, with the change boxed

The review card is your own Loox pop-up, as it opened over the basket during our visit.

What we found

  • Your pagesIn the phone basket the review card covers the left of the Checkout+ and checkout buttons.
  • Your pagesOn the phone product page the same card covers the lower left of the main photo.
  • Best practiceNothing should sit over a checkout button; reviews work best beside the product, not on top of it.

The idea

Because a floating review card opens over the checkout buttons in the phone basket and over the main product photo, we think keeping it off the basket and away from the photo on phones will clear the way to checkout, for phone shoppers.

Reach
Everyone on phones
Impact
MediumA solid win, behind the top ideas
How sure
HunchBacked by your pages and good practice
Next step
Just do itA pop-up covering checkout is a fix, not a test.
Measure it by: Checkout starts from the basket on phones
5
FixHunch

Say when the Black Friday offer ends

Banner, top bar and basket
The phone home page banner with the Black Friday tiers and no end date.
The phone home page banner with the Black Friday tiers and no end date.

What we found

  • Your pagesBlack Friday tiers show in the banner, top bar and basket; no end date is stated on any page we visited.
  • Best practiceA real end date gives a reason to decide today; an invented one costs trust.

The idea

Because the Black Friday tiers show in the banner, top bar and basket but no end date is given anywhere we looked, we think stating the real end date will give shoppers a reason to buy now rather than later, for every visitor during the event. This one only applies while the Black Friday event runs.

Reach
Every visitor
Impact
LowWorth doing, smaller than the rest
How sure
HunchBacked by your pages and good practice
Next step
Just do itThe event is short, so there is no time to test it; just add the date.
Measure it by: Orders per day during the event
How you compare

What two competitors do on the same product page

The first phone screen of each product page, captured the same day. Only what bears on getting someone to buy.

By Teddy product page on a phone
By TeddyYour product page, first phone screen
Mutts & Hounds home page on a phone
Mutts & Hounds
  • Product page on a phone: name, photo and an ADD TO CART bar all in the first screen
  • Under the button: "Free delivery on all UK orders over £150." with a van icon
  • Second top bar: "READ OUR TOP RATED CUSTOMER REVIEWS"
Hugo & Hudson home page on a phone
Hugo & Hudson
  • Product page on a phone: name and "£15.00 GBP" in the first screen
  • Top bar: "Free UK Shipping On Orders Over £50* Excluding Beds"
  • Top bar: "Sign up to our newsletter and enjoy 15% off your first purchase."
The scorecard

12 of 20 checks passed

31 checks drawn from large studies of how people shop online. 20 of them could be answered from your public pages on desktop and phone; the rest need your store settings or analytics, and say so.

Product page4 of 7 passed
  • Delivery cost, or the free delivery line, shown on the product pageOnly inside a closed tab: "Complimentary UK Shipping Over £75"
    Needs work
  • Returns policy summary or link on the product pageReturns only in the footer, or not at all
    Needs work
  • Delivery date or cut-off time statedNo delivery date or order-by time on the product page
    Needs work
  • Sizes or variants are picked with buttons, not a dropdown10 option buttons, no dropdown
    Passed
  • At least 3 product images, one showing scale or the product in use16 images. Product photos show dogs wearing the knit, sitting and standing, so the size reads clearly.
    Passed
  • Star rating with review count near the product nameReview stars beside the product name
    Passed
  • Add to basket reachable without scrolling on a phone, or a sticky add to basketSticky add to basket while scrolling
    Passed
Collections2 of 4 passed
  • Filters on collections with more than 20 productsNo filters found
    Needs work
  • Sort by price, rating, best selling and newestNo sort options found
    Needs work
  • Variants of one product shown as one card, not many24 products, one card each
    Passed
  • Sold-out products last or hiddenNo sold-out products in the first row
    Passed
Basket and checkout1 of 2 passed
  • Free delivery progress shown in the basketNothing about free delivery in the basket
    Needs work
  • Quantity changed with + and - buttons in the basketPlus and minus buttons
    Passed
Offers and pricing0 of 1 passed
  • A time-limited offer shows when it endsBlack Friday tiers shown in the banner, bar and basket; no end date stated anywhere seen.
    Needs work
Trust2 of 3 passed
  • Returns or a guarantee stated across the siteNo returns promise on home or product; free returns only appear as a paid basket add-on.
    Needs work
  • Reviews from a recognised platform, with the countHome shows 5/5 from 1,324 reviews under the hero on desktop; product shows five stars.
    Passed
  • Contact options easy to findEmail, phone, contact page or chat linked
    Passed
Homepage and navigation3 of 3 passed
  • Products in hero and lifestyle images can be reached in one tapHero carries a Shop Black Friday button at both widths.
    Passed
  • Carousels do not turn by themselves on a phoneThe carousel stays put
    Passed
  • Search visible in the phone headerSearch in the phone header
    Passed
How this audit works

Where every figure comes from

Next steps

Taking it further

This is a free first look, from your pages and policies as any shopper sees them. It does not use your analytics, so reach and ranking are judged from the pages, not from your visits. Each idea is a starting point: before anything is built we would look into it properly, with your numbers, and come back with a plan and a quote.

Next step for By Teddy

If any of this is useful, the quickest way on is a short call or a reply. We will tell you honestly what is worth doing first, and what it would cost.

Get in touchor just reply to the email
Tim Fowler, Founder and Shopify developer, Cartmasters

On East at Home, a store we built, revenue rose 82% and the conversion rate 14% in the eight months after launch, against the same period the year before (their Google Analytics). See our work